“If a doctor is not happy with what Medicare paid for your care, can that doctor charge you extra money – out of your own pocket?”
That is the question I asked hundreds of people during my years selling Medicare insurance to see if they fully understood how Medicare works. Half of those questioned answered a resounding “no, doctors can’t charge you extra.” The other half answered, “yes, I believe they can.”
Sometimes even husbands and wives had widely differing opinions on that very important and potentially costly question. But nobody ever had the exact, precise answer.
Some doctors can bill you for up to 15% more than what Medicare thinks a procedure is worth. Medicare officially calls this 15% payment a Part B Excess Charge.
Since this can be an issue that’s costly to you, let’s answer the question in full. Then you will understand the choices you have. You can either:
- Pay the extra charges yourself
- Avoid the extra charges by using different doctors
- Choose a specific Medicare Supplement plan that will pay those extra charges for you
How Doctors Can Bill You Part B Excess Charges
How Much Are These Charges?
In some circumstances, doctors can add up to an extra 15% to your bill. Medicare officially calls this 15% payment a Part B Excess Charge.
The two questions that this brings up are:
1) When can doctors charge you the extra 15%?
2) If you are charged, who pays the bill?
Recall the Basics of Medicare
If you are on Original Medicare, then you’ll have Medicare Part A and Medicare Part B from the federal government. Most likely you’ll have a Medicare Part D prescription plan that you purchased from an insurance company, and a Medicare Supplement plan (also called Medigap) purchased from an insurance company. Great so far.
Medicare Advantage (Medicare Part C) plans don’t deal with excess charges since these plans are private replacements for Part A & B coverage. They have their own copayments and deductibles.
A Very Clear Description of Excess Charges
Suppose you need an echocardiogram. Also, suppose that Medicare has set the doctor’s pay for this procedure at $100. When Medicare sets a doctor’s fee like that, it’s called the Medicare Approved Amount. It’s worth noting that most of the care you receive from doctors is indeed under a schedule of fixed prices that Medicare has set.
Now let’s assume that you can choose from among three doctors to have the echocardiogram. Here are the three scenarios you can face:
The Doctor Accepts Medicare Assignment
In this case, the doctor will be paid $80 by Medicare, provided you’ve already met your Part B deductible for the calendar year. Then, either you or your Medigap insurance will pay your doctor the other $20.
That’s it. Since the doctor “takes assignment,” meaning he has agreed to accept the payment terms of Medicare, he can NOT charge you anything else.
The Doctor Takes Medicare But NOT Medicare Assignment
If the doctor doesn’t accept assignment, the approved amount – the part Medicare pays plus your coinsurance – is set at 95% of the normal Medicare-approved amount. This means Medicare would approve $95 for the echocardiogram and pay the doctor $76. The patient’s coinsurance would be $19.
Then the doctor is allowed to charge an extra 15% on the original amount. In this case, the patient would owe another $14.25 (15% of $95). In total, going to a doctor who does not accept Medicare assignment for a $100 procedure, will cost the patient $33.25
If you have Medigap Plan F or G, however, the entire amount, including the 20% copayment and the 15% excess charge is covered. And any Medigap plan will pay some or all of the $19 charge.
What About Big Doctor Bills, Like Surgery?
So far we’ve only mentioned a little $100 bill. What if you have a surgeon’s bill, an anesthesiologist’s bill, and a radiologist’s bill, and they total $20,000? If each doctor charges you that extra 15%, you could be $3,000 out of pocket.
For what specific procedures can doctors charge the extra 15%? Those are defined by Medicare. If in doubt about the cost of a procedure that you need, ask your doctor.
The Doctor Does Not Take Medicare At All
Most doctors who treat seniors take Medicare. But exceptions do exist; 3,700 doctors nationwide had opted out of Medicare as of 2017.
If your doctor does not accept any type of Medicare, you will have to pay the total bill yourself. Medicare is not involved at all and will not pay ANY part of it, including not reimbursing you after the service.
Common Excess Charge Scenarios
Medicare agents report seeing Part B Excess Charges most often with people who have multiple chronic ailments. Those people have so many doctors that at least one doctor typically doesn’t accept Medicare assignment. The patient, not wanting to switch medical networks, will be stuck paying that extra charge for every visit with that doctor.
Ways to Avoid Part B Excess Charges
Check With Your Doctor In Advance
Ask your doctor’s office if he or she accepts Medicare assignment.
- If the answer is yes, then they can’t even think about applying the Part B Excess Charge.
- If the answer is no, but they do take Medicare, then the doctor in most states can apply the excess charge. Ask if they are planning to add the charge to your bill.
Eight States Prohibit Medicare Excess Charges
A handful of states protect you from some Part B Excess Charges. For example, New York limits the excess charge to 5%. The others on the list may ban the excess charge completely or restrict the amount to less than 15%.
- New York,
- Rhode Island, and
If you live in one of these states and see doctors in one of these states, then you may not be subject to the full 15% extra charge.
Medigap Plans F and G Pay Excess Charges
If the thought of paying these Part B Excess Charges bothers you, consider enrolling in Medicare Supplement Plans F or G. Be aware that Plan F is no longer, as of 2020, available to newly-eligible beneficiaries.
Everyone who chooses these government-regulated add-ons to Medicare doesn’t have to pay excess charges. There are currently 10 different types of Medigap plans available, but only those two plan types include excess charge assistance.
Reimbursement for Excess Charges
If your medical provider accepts Medicare, they can still fill out the appropriate paperwork to get Medicare’s share of their payment, even if you’re responsible for excess charges. If the provider has opted out of dealing with Medicare entirely, Medicare won’t pay them or reimburse the patient. For patients who want their secondary insurance to cover a claim after being denied coverage from Medicare, they can file a Medicare Patient’s Request for Payment Form.
Taking The Next Steps
Medicare is one of the best healthcare systems in the world. In order to enjoy it fully, you must make wise choices when deciding how you will receive your benefits. Let us know if you need help – we enjoy hearing from you.